A dialogue on brands in culture, by Anne Vaschetto and Matt McMullen
Every brand holds onto something at its Core. Call it conviction: the belief that stays put while everything else moves and shifts around it. In Brand Flux, Culture is the ‘everything else.’ And it moves a lot faster than most brands do.
For a long stretch, brands could set the pace. A sharp idea and a big media budget could start a conversation and steer it, sometimes for years. That window has closed. Audiences know the playbook, creators and communities make the culture, and the whole thing turns over in weeks or months.
Brands still have a place in it; they just have to earn it, again and again.
At Moxie Sozo, we define Culture like this:
Culture is the environment a brand operates in: the people who buy from it, work for it, and believe in it, plus the outside forces acting on all of them.
How it used to work
Anne: A lot of my favorite brands have been around a while, so I’ve watched how they show up over the years. The first car I bought for myself was a British Racing Green MINI Cooper S, right after their US launch campaign. Right away, I felt like a part of the community. I joined local meet-ups and hunted through their ads with my MINI decoder kit to find clues and win collector's items. Even the owner’s manual was an insider's guide full of wit. I definitely geeked out over that level of brand experience.
Early in my career, we’d spend years developing and fine-tuning strategy, design, and campaigns with big production budgets. They often wouldn’t hit the market until years later, and by then you were already onto the next one to keep the cadence. Brands and campaigns would have lifespans of 5-10 years at that time. That worked then. We’ve moved on.
Matt: I grew up right as brands moved online. My childhood was mostly offline, but by my teens, more and more posts were sponsored, influencing moved from side gigs to full-time jobs, and brand accounts with their own “unique” personalities were everywhere. By college, people my age could clock a marketing tactic in a few seconds. Now pretty much everyone can, at any age. And once people can spot the tactic, it slowly stops working on them.
Everyone knows the playbook now
Brands live inside culture. They don’t run it, and the ones that act like they do are usually the first to fall out of step.
Matt: Audience literacy changes what a brand has to bring. Look at the Super Bowl. The old formula was set for years and years: be funny, grab attention, premiere on game day. Now spots drop a week or two early, because that’s the only way anyone might see them. A spot has to make sense for the brand and for the exact moment it lands in, so timelines keep shrinking and most briefs now say “ASAP.” Poppi has pulled this off three years running. Every spot sounds like Poppi and fits its moment, because the brand knows what it wants to say. Without that conviction, it’s easy for people to see right through it.
Catching up all at once
Most brands notice culture shifting late, then try to win relevance back in one big, expensive swing. A new campaign, a new look, a new voice. It turns into a scramble, and the brand usually loses some of its Core along the way.
Anne: I saw this happen from the inside at Clif Bar. Every new campaign reached for what was on trend and relevant in the moment. They were fun and exciting to work on, but each one drifted a little further from what the brand stood for. It took a lot of internal work to get back to the brand’s Core, and what stuck with me there was how critical it is to show up with the right balance of authenticity and relevance.
Anne: I saw this happen from the inside at Clif Bar. Every new campaign reached for what was on trend and relevant in the moment. They were fun and exciting to work on, but each one drifted a little further from what the brand stood for. It took a lot of internal work to get back to the brand’s Core, and what stuck with me there was how critical it is to show up with the right balance of authenticity and relevance.
To catch a shift early, you have to know what you’re watching, and what you’re holding onto.
What it looks like
Keeping up with culture is a habit. Something you do all year.
Change with culture. We believe that the market won’t wait for your next rebrand. When we change with culture, the brand keeps pace with the people around it instead of catching up every five years.
In practice, that means paying attention all the time and making small moves, so the brand never has far to catch up. It also means knowing which shifts belong to your brand and which ones to let pass.
Anne: When everyone jumps on the same trend, every version starts to look the same. The brands worth watching now pay attention to the bigger themes moving through culture and ask what they can contribute. They don’t just copy what others are doing—they find connections to what’s relevant to their core to show up in a way that’s authentic and unique to them. Then they move in steps small enough to take often. This not only helps them avoid bigger productions, but also keeps them naturally part of the conversation.
Matt: The clients I love working with know what they’re walking into. A lot of brands launch these days with making money as the whole plan. The founders who show up with a conviction that reaches past that are the ones I’d bet on. When culture shifts, they have something to anchor to.
We’re in Flux, too.
We hold ourselves to the same standard. At Moxie Sozo, we partner with brands big and small, and with each one, speed and adaptability earn people’s attention. That goes for us, too. Our own definition of Culture started as a “shared reality.” Once we put Flux to work, we rewrote it to name the environment a brand operates in and the outside forces pushing on it. And we’ll keep rewriting it as we learn.
The people who work for a brand are part of its culture too, and that includes us. We put a lot of energy into how our team works together: more intentional, more equitable across departments, clearer roles. It changed how we do the work. We know when to lean on each other and when to step up and lead.
So here’s where we land. Culture is something we work inside every day, for our clients and for ourselves. We watch it closely, we hold tight to what each brand stands for, and we adjust in small steps so nobody has to scramble. Seeing the shift is half the work. Deciding what to do about it is the other half, and it’s the half we love.